By: G. Ray Gompf, CD
There was a point in history when truckers made a decent living and not all that’s long ago. Deregulation didn’t help maintain those decent wages, but it was a slower pace of decline than since 2011.
Once upon a time, truck drivers weren’t paid by the mile but by the hour because carriers knew exactly how many hours each driver worked but then the classification “owner operator” was created and a whole different “by the mile” became the norm for both owner operator contractors and company drivers alike. Hourly wages became a lost consideration for all but a few classifications.
By the mile often produced income below the provincial minimum wage. Back in 1996 I produced a spread sheet to determine my real costs per mile, and it was near $2.37 cents then. Yet, the average owner operator compensation was often under $1.00 per mile and far too often owner operators couldn’t take their own wages.
I personally recognized that my rate, in the $1.20 range, just wasn’t cutting it, so I got my own insurance coverage, and worked with load brokers I knew and trusted. I refused to take loads under an amount that wasn’t producing enough revenue to pay for every item on my spreadsheet including my wages.
I was also running produce out of Florida then and rates then were pretty good. Tomatoes and watermelon paid well to the Toronto or Montreal markets so I’d find a load that would cover return fuel plus a bit to Florida and the return load to Canada paid insurance, truck payment, my wages well above minimum wage, tires, maintenance and assorted items. Communication costs were covered back then in those rates. It was a spreadsheet item most guys forgot was costing them a lot.
Today, with fuel prices triple from the early 2,000 years, rates out of the produce belts, like Florida, are now less than half of what they were back then.
Basically, those carriers that did well, started to stop eating losses and smaller carriers operating on the concept of “if the wheels are turning you can keep it in the black”. Frankly they can only keep it in the black by watching every penny of cost and simply stop maintaining equipment. Cutting wages. Run tires to bald praying they aren’t called in for any kind of inspection. Then the hiring of ill-trained operators, all to cut costs.
Truly, those that cut too much muscle can only sustain until something goes haywire. Wages are a calculable number for which budgeting will sustain. Maintenance and repairs also is quite calculable and must be sustained by an adequate budget.
Flat out though, if the rate isn’t there the budgets get cut. If the budgets get cut, then the stability of the operation slips into the questionable category.
He who does not operate on a strict budget, knowing fully what his numbers are, all of them, is destined for an appointment with an insolvency trustee. He who takes under-priced freight ever, is deluding himself. Freight moved must pay enough for at the very least one penny of profit per mile, or it should sit on the shipper’s dock, forever if need be.
Frankly, it doesn’t matter whether you’re a one truck operation or a thousand truck operation, no one can move freight below cost for very long. He who works for a carrier who consistently uses cheap freight to keep the wheels turning should start to look for another carrier for which to work, who doesn’t.
There is good freight out there that pays very well. As a small business owner operator trucker, you don’t have the time or energy to find it so you may have to rely on load brokers. Like any competitive business there are good load brokers who understand their necessary position in the supply chain and then there are those load brokers who want to cover their entire costs with a single load. It’s a trial-and-error thing, but keep immaculate records of who you call, the result of that experience. If you find people using your equipment to finance their lavish lifestyle, find another that understands without you performing well, they are merely another link in the supply chain.


